# Heat Pump Replacement in Aurora, CO

> Heat pump or AC failing in Aurora? We price the repair and the replacement side by side, size the new system from a load calculation and itemize every part.

URL: https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/heat-pump-replacement/

When a heat pump or AC starts failing, we put the repair and the replacement side by side, then size any new system from the house rather than the old label.

- **Our typical range:** $13,000 to $25,000 for a cold-climate ducted replacement
- Repair and replacement priced side by side when the answer is close
- Every estimate includes a load calculation, duct and airflow checks and a panel check

A heat pump or central AC that needs refrigerant every summer, trips its breaker or no longer keeps up leaves you with one question before any other: fix it once more, or replace it. Sundog replaces heat pumps and central air conditioners across Aurora and the towns around it, and we answer that question with both options priced on paper, not with a sales pitch for new equipment.

When replacement is the right call, it is more than a swap of the box in the side yard. The outdoor unit, the indoor coil or air handler and the controls have to be matched to each other and to the house. Some parts of the old system can stay and some cannot, and the size of the new one should come from a load calculation, not the sticker on the old one. Sundog's typical range for a cold-climate ducted replacement on suitable existing ducts is $13,000 to $25,000, set at the site visit and in the written estimate. If you are still choosing between system types, start with [ducted heat pump installation](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/heat-pump-installation/).

## Replacing a 4-ton system with a 3-ton one

Commerce City: New condensing furnace with PVC intake and exhaust pipes in a basement.

The same scene in a thermal view.

Project price

$22,400

On site

3 days

Where

Commerce City

The house

2000s two-story, unfinished basement

Replacement is where sizing mistakes get copied. This 2000s Commerce City two-story, about 2,300 square feet over an unfinished basement, came with a 4-ton AC that needed refrigerant every summer and an 80% furnace whose inducer had turned loud. On mild days the system short cycled, a sign it had been oversized from the start.

Our load calculation for the newer, tighter envelope came to 3 tons, so we replaced down rather than like for like. The new equipment was a 3-ton cold-climate variable-speed heat pump with a matched coil and a 96% two-stage furnace, which kept gas for the coldest stretches. The ducts were sized for 4 tons, so they gave the smaller variable-speed blower plenty of room.

Changing to a condensing furnace brought its own work. About 18 feet of 2-inch PVC intake and exhaust ran out through the rim joist, with the terminations held clear of windows and the narrow side-yard property line. Condensate drained through a neutralizer to the floor drain. The water heater was left venting alone into a flue sized for two appliances, so we relined that flue and ran a combustion test on both appliances.

At start-up we set the changeover point, checked charge, airflow and both heating modes, and booked the city's gas and mechanical inspection.

## What happens on the first visit

A replacement visit starts with the system you already have. We look at what failed, what it cost you before, and which parts are worth keeping.

### The old system's history

We read the nameplates on the outdoor unit, coil and furnace or air handler for age, size and refrigerant type, and ask what has been repaired before. A system that needs refrigerant every year has a leak, and that history says more than its age.

### Room-by-room load

We measure the house and run the heating and cooling load. If the result is smaller than the old nameplate, the replacement goes down a size; if the house has grown, it may go up.

### The indoor side

We read static pressure at the blower and look at the coil, blower motor and cabinet to decide whether the indoor equipment stays, takes a new coil or is replaced with a matched air handler.

### Panel, line set and pad

We check the breaker and wire feeding the outdoor unit, the [panel's room](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/guide/electrical-panel-for-heat-pump/) for any backup heat, the size and condition of the line set, and whether the pad sits above the snow.

## Repair it again or replace it

No single age or dollar figure decides this. We weigh the refrigerant, the failed part, the repair history and how well the system ever heated the house, and when the answer is close you get both prices in writing. Our [repair or replacement guide](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-repair-vs-replacement/) walks through the same questions if you want to weigh it first.

### A repair usually makes sense when

The system runs on a current refrigerant, it kept the house comfortable until now, and the failed part is a capacitor, contactor, fan motor, sensor or control board. Sundog's typical range for routine heat pump repair is $150 to $1,200, and fixing a sound system for that money is usually the right call. Our [heat pump repair](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/heat-pump-repair/) visits find the cause before anything is replaced.

### Replacement usually makes sense when

The compressor or reversing valve has failed on an older system, the leak keeps coming back, or the system still runs on R-22, which has not been produced in the U.S. since 2020. Major component work runs $1,500 to $3,500 in our typical range, and spending that on equipment near the end of its life buys time rather than a fix. Replacement also makes sense when the system never kept the house comfortable, because a system sized to the house can.

## Same size, or the size the house needs

Ducts built for the larger system usually carry the smaller one easily.

Most replacement quotes copy the tonnage on the old unit. That is the quickest way to repeat a mistake. Builders often sized generously, many houses have since gained new windows, attic insulation or air sealing, and an oversized heat pump short cycles on mild days, dries the air poorly in summer and costs more up front.

We run the load calculation first and let it set the size; in the Commerce City house above, that meant 3 tons in place of 4. The answer can go the other way too: a finished basement or an addition can push the load above what the old system was built for. Our [sizing guide](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-sizing/) shows how the calculation works.

A new size also changes what the ducts see. Ducts built for a larger system usually carry a smaller one easily. Ducts that were already tight for the old system are a problem to fix before the new one goes in, because a variable-speed heat pump works harder against a high static-pressure reading than the old single-speed unit ever did. Our guide to [ductwork for heat pumps](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/guide/ductwork-for-heat-pumps/) covers the usual fixes.

## What can stay and what has to go

Reusing parts of the old system saves money only where the part is sound and suits the new equipment. Here is how we decide, part by part.

### Line set

Copper lines can stay when they are the right diameter for the new unit, free of kinks and leaks, and suited to the new refrigerant. Lines from an R-22 system, undersized lines and lines buried in a finished wall with unknown joints are usually replaced. A reused line set is pressure-tested with nitrogen and evacuated before charging.

### Indoor coil and air handler

A new outdoor unit performs as rated only with a matched indoor coil, and rebate programs usually ask for the matched pair's model numbers, so the coil almost always changes with it. A sound air handler cabinet can sometimes stay, but a single-speed blower behind a variable-speed outdoor unit throws away much of what you paid for.

### Ducts

Ducts usually stay. We seal the joints we can reach, replace crushed runs and add return where the static-pressure reading calls for it, each priced as its own line. The [installation process guide](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-installation-process/) shows where that work fits in the schedule.

### Pad, wiring and thermostat

A level pad or stand above the snow line can stay. The disconnect and wire stay when they match the new unit's breaker size. Thermostats often change, because variable-speed equipment and staged backup need controls that can run them. Moving the unit? See [where the outdoor unit should go](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/blog/heat-pump-outdoor-unit-placement/).

## When only the furnace or air handler is the problem

Sometimes the outdoor unit is young and the indoor side is what failed: a blower motor, a cracked drain pan, a cabinet that has rusted through. Replacing only the air handler is a job we price from the visit rather than from a range. The blower type, the size of any electric backup, how the cabinet fits the closet or basement, and whether the coil must change with it all set the price.

If you heat with a furnace and only the AC has failed, there is another route: a heat pump in the AC's place, working with the furnace you keep. That is [dual fuel](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/dual-fuel-heat-pump/), and it is often the cheapest way to add heat-pump heating to a house whose furnace still has years left. If you want to leave gas entirely, the replacement becomes a [cold-climate system](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/cold-climate-heat-pump-installation/) with electric backup instead.

## Rebates on a replacement

A replacement can qualify for incentives a repair never will. Xcel Energy runs a residential heat-pump rebate for qualifying equipment at qualifying service addresses, and Aurora's F-3 program covers a mapped area with active Xcel gas service. Both depend on the address, the matched equipment and how the job is installed, and both have their own installation and application dates, so check the current program dates before you plan around them. We check what applies to your house before the estimate is final, and the model numbers the programs ask for go on the estimate; our [incentive checklist](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-installation-incentive-checklist/) lists the paperwork. The federal 25C tax credit ended for systems installed after 2025. Our [Aurora rebate guide](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-rebates-aurora/) explains each program, and the [cost page](https://sundogauroraheatpumps.com/heat-pump-installation-cost/) shows how a replacement price is built.

## What is included in a replacement

- Refrigerant recovered from the old system before anything is disconnected, and the old equipment hauled away
- Matched outdoor unit and indoor coil or air handler, with model numbers and low-temperature capacity on the estimate
- A new line set, or the old one pressure-tested and evacuated where it passes the reuse checks
- Pad or stand above the snow line, disconnect, and any breaker or wire change the new unit needs
- Duct and return fixes found on the visit, each on its own line
- Mechanical permit, plus an electrical permit where circuits change; Aurora sets the fee by scope
- Thermostat and backup controls set up and tested in heating and cooling
- Start-up readings and model numbers left with you, along with rebate paperwork

## Repair, like-for-like or a resized replacement

|  | Repair | Like-for-like replacement | Replacement sized to the house |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Best fit | A sound system with one failed part | Only when the load calculation matches the old size | Most replacements, especially older or oversized systems |
| What you keep | Everything else | Often the line set, pad and ducts | Whatever passes the reuse checks |
| Main risk | Paying for parts on a system near its end | Copying an old sizing or airflow problem | Ducts that were already tight for the old system |
| Our typical range | $150 to $1,200 routine; $1,500 to $3,500 major components | $13,000 to $25,000 cold-climate ducted | $13,000 to $25,000; $19,000 to $28,000 with a new furnace |

## Related resources

Heat pump repair vs replacement

The failed part, the refrigerant the system runs on and whether it ever heated the house well decide most of it.

Heat pump sizing

Size comes from what your house loses on a cold night and gains on a hot afternoon, matched to equipment by its output in the cold.

Installation process

From the first visit to the city's inspection, here is the order of the work, what each step proves and what you should have in hand at the end.

## How the job runs

1. **Visit** Old system, load, ducts, panel
2. **Written estimate** Repair and replacement on paper
3. **Permits** Mechanical, electrical where circuits change
4. **Install** Usually one to four days
5. **Start-up** Readings recorded, city inspection

## Questions about heat pump replacement

### Is my heat pump too old to repair?

Age alone does not decide it. A system on a current refrigerant with a failed capacitor is worth fixing; an R-22 system with a failed compressor usually is not. When it is close, we price both.

### Should the new heat pump be the same size as the old one?

Only if the load calculation says so. Many older systems were oversized, and houses change. We size from the room-by-room calculation and show you the numbers.

### Can you reuse my existing line set?

Sometimes. It has to be the right size, sound and suited to the new refrigerant. Lines from R-22 systems and undersized lines are replaced; reused lines are pressure-tested and evacuated first.

### Can I replace just the outdoor unit?

Rarely a good idea. The outdoor unit and indoor coil are rated as a matched pair, and rebates usually ask for the matched model numbers. We quote the matched replacement and explain any exception.

### What does the written estimate include?

Model numbers and low-temperature capacity, duct and electrical work, the permit, removal, the pad or stand and the start-up checks, each on its own line.

## Related services

Ducted heat pump installation

Before we recommend a heat pump, we measure the house: room by room for the load, at the blower for airflow, at the panel for capacity.

Dual-fuel heat pump

A heat pump for most of the winter, your gas furnace for the coldest nights, and controls that decide which one runs.

Heat pump repair

Cool air in heat mode, ice that will not clear, a breaker that trips.

## Heat pump replacement in Aurora

Measured first, sized to the house, every item in writing.
