Last Updated: November 2026
The short answer
It depends on your own rates more than on the equipment. Take the all-in cost per kWh and per therm from your Xcel bills, the heat pump's COP at each outdoor temperature, and the point where backup heat starts. With those three you can price a unit of heat from each source. A generic monthly figure tells you little.
Find your real rates on your Xcel bill
The rate printed on a tariff page is only one piece of what you pay. Riders, fixed charges and adjustments sit on top, so work from your bill instead. Xcel's residential electric energy charge is also seasonal, lower in the winter months than in summer, which matters for heating.
- Pick a winter electric bill. Divide the total electric charges, less the fixed monthly service charge, by the kWh used. That is your all-in cost per kWh.
- Do the same on the gas side: total gas charges, less the fixed charge, divided by therms used.
- Repeat for two or three winter months. Gas cost adjustments move month to month, so an average is safer than one bill.
- Check which electric plan you are on. If it bills by time of day, note the rate in the hours your heat runs most.
- Keep the numbers. We use them to set the changeover point on a dual-fuel system.
How much heat each kWh buys
A heat pump's efficiency is its coefficient of performance, or COP: units of heat delivered per unit of electricity. It is not one number.
COP falls as it gets colder
Moving heat from 50°F air is easy; moving it from 0°F air is hard. So COP is highest in mild weather and lowest on the coldest nights, and capacity drops the same way. ENERGY STAR's cold-climate designation requires a COP of at least 1.75 at 5°F and at least 70% of the unit's 47°F capacity at that temperature.
Where to find your model's numbers
Manufacturers publish extended performance tables with COP and capacity at several outdoor temperatures. We put the low-temperature capacity on every written estimate, and we read the COP curve with you when the running-cost question matters. Our cold-weather performance guide explains the curve.
What a unit of heat costs from each source
Once you have rates and COP, you can price heat the same way for every source. The table uses $0.13 per kWh and $1.00 per therm as round inputs, not as Xcel's rates; put your own numbers into the same arithmetic.
| Heat source | Efficiency | Cost per million BTU delivered at $0.13/kWh or $1.00/therm |
|---|---|---|
| Heat pump on a mild day | COP 4 | $9.52 |
| 96% gas furnace | AFUE 96% | $10.42 |
| 80% gas furnace | AFUE 80% | $12.50 |
| Heat pump in moderate cold | COP 3 | $12.70 |
| Heat pump in hard cold | COP 2 | $19.05 |
| Cold-climate minimum at 5°F | COP 1.75 | $21.77 |
| Electric strip or baseboard | COP 1 | $38.10 |
Two things stand out. At these rates a heat pump beats an 80% furnace above about COP 3.1 and a 96% furnace above about COP 3.7. And electric strip heat costs far more than either, which is why backup heat is sized to the gap and locked out in mild weather.
Want your own number? We start from your house and your bills.
Get an EstimateWhere backup heat takes over
Most of a Colorado heating season is spent in mild and moderate weather, where the heat pump's COP is high. The bill is shaped by how the coldest hours are handled.
With a furnace (dual fuel)
The controls switch to gas below a set outdoor temperature. We set that point from your rates and the heat pump's COP curve, so each hour runs on the cheaper source rather than on habit.
All-electric
An electric strip in the air handler covers the gap when the heat pump cannot keep up, and during defrost. We stage it with an outdoor sensor and lock it out above a set temperature, so it runs only when needed.
What else moves the bill
The rates and COP set the price of heat. These set how much of it you buy, and which source supplies it.
Backup running too often
A thermostat that calls for strip heat on every recovery, or a lockout set too high, adds cost fast. A common cause of a high first-winter bill.
Ducts that leak or choke airflow
Heat lost in a crawlspace or attic is paid for twice. Low airflow also lowers the heat pump's output. See our ductwork guide.
Deep setbacks
Big overnight setbacks can trigger backup heat on the morning recovery. Smaller setbacks, or a heat-pump-aware thermostat, avoid it.
Sizing
An oversized system short-cycles in mild weather; an undersized one leans on backup. Both cost money. Sizing comes from a load calculation.
Summer counts too
A heat pump replaces your central AC, so its summer running cost replaces the AC's. A new variable-speed unit is usually more efficient than an older single-stage AC, rated by SEER2. Compare cooling with cooling and heating with heating, rather than one annual bill with another.
Bring your bills to the estimate
Sundog installs and services heat pumps across Aurora and nearby towns. Call (719) 417-2475 or request an estimate and have two or three winter bills ready. We work from your rates and your house, not a national average. To compare fuels side by side, see heat pump or gas furnace, and for installed prices see our typical ranges.
Get an EstimateQuestions people ask
Will a heat pump lower my heating bill?
It depends on your rates, your old system and how the backup is set. Against electric resistance heat it almost always costs less to run. Against gas the answer changes with the temperature and your two rates, so we work it out from your bills.
Why did my bill go up the first winter?
The usual causes are backup heat running more than it should, deep thermostat setbacks or a lockout temperature set too high. A service visit can check the controls and the staging.
What COP should I look for?
Look at the COP and capacity at 5°F as well as the rating at 47°F. ENERGY STAR's cold-climate mark requires at least COP 1.75 at 5°F; higher is better on cold nights.

