Last Updated: November 2026
Most Colorado heat pumps use one of two backups: electric resistance strips in the indoor air handler, or a gas furnace in a dual-fuel setup. Some well-insulated houses with a strong cold-climate unit need only a small strip. Which fits depends on the house's heat loss, the unit's output at 5°F, your panel and your gas and electric rates.
No option is cheapest for every house. We size the backup to the gap our load calculation finds, and we show you the cold-night numbers before you choose between dual fuel and an all-electric system.
The three ways to cover the cold hours
Each option does the same job, heat for the hours below the balance point and during defrost, with different trade-offs. Backup also matters on the night something fails: if the outdoor unit stops, the backup is what keeps the pipes and the house warm until it is repaired, so we never size it to zero without talking it through.
| Electric strip backup | Dual fuel (gas furnace) | Small or no backup | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How it works | Resistance coils in the air handler switch on in stages | The furnace takes over below a set outdoor temperature | The heat pump carries nearly all hours; a small strip covers defrost |
| What it needs | Panel capacity for the strip circuit | A furnace in good shape whose blower and coil match the heat pump | Low heat loss and strong 5°F output |
| Running cost depends on | Your electric rate; strips deliver 1 unit of heat per unit of electricity | Your gas rate and furnace efficiency | Mostly the heat pump's efficiency |
| Watch for | Strips running when the heat pump can carry the load | A changeover set by habit, not by numbers | A cold-snap shortfall if the load was guessed |
Sizing electric backup to the gap
One kilowatt of resistance heat delivers 3,412 BTU per hour. That makes strip sizing simple arithmetic once the load calculation is done.
The math
A 5 kW strip delivers about 17,000 BTU per hour; a 10 kW strip about 34,000. At 240 volts, 10 kW draws roughly 42 amps before the circuit is sized, which is why a strip that is bigger than the gap costs panel space it never uses.
Staging and lockout
Strips should come on in stages and stay locked out above an outdoor temperature where the heat pump can carry the house. Without a lockout, a thermostat can call for strips on a mild morning simply because the house is recovering. Our panel guide covers the circuits.
How a dual-fuel system decides which one runs
In a dual-fuel house the controls switch from heat pump to furnace at a changeover temperature. There are two ways to set it, and the better changeover uses both.
The comfort point
The balance point: the outdoor temperature where the heat pump stops keeping up with the house. Below it, the furnace has to take over or the house cools.
The cost point
Compare the cost of 100,000 BTU of delivered heat. From gas, that is one therm divided by the furnace's efficiency. From the heat pump, it is 29.3 kWh times your electric rate divided by the heat pump's COP at that temperature. We run it on your own Xcel rates.
Want your own number? We start from your house and your bills.
Get an EstimateControls make or break the backup
The same equipment can run efficiently or expensively depending on how the controls are set up. These are the settings we confirm at start-up and leave in writing with you.
- An outdoor sensor, so changeover and lockout follow the actual temperature
- Strip lockout above a set outdoor temperature, and staged strips below it
- Defrost tempering, so the backup warms the air briefly while the coil defrosts
- A thermostat that knows it is running a heat pump, with the right number of stages
- Gentle recovery after a setback, so a morning warm-up doesn't bring on the strips
Should I turn the thermostat down at night?
With a furnace, deep setbacks save gas. With a heat pump, the answer depends on the backup and the controls.
Electric strip backup
A small setback of a few degrees, or none, usually works best. A deep setback can make the morning recovery call on the strips, the most expensive heat in the house.
Dual fuel
Setbacks behave more like they did with the furnace, because the furnace handles recovery on cold mornings. The changeover setting still matters.
Smart thermostats
Many offer a heat-pump recovery mode that warms the house slowly. We set it to match the backup you have.
Which backup fits which house
These are the places we start the conversation, not fixed answers.
Lean toward dual fuel
The furnace has good years left, the AC is the part that failed, or the panel has little room for a large strip. See furnace-to-heat-pump conversion if you are weighing it.
Lean toward electric backup
The furnace is near the end of its life, the house has room on the panel, you want to drop gas, and a cold-climate model covers most of the load at 5°F.
Lean toward a small backup
Newer, tighter houses with a low heat loss, where the 5°F output of the chosen unit covers the design load or nearly does. A small strip still covers defrost and a failed outdoor unit.
Choosing with your numbers
Bring a year of Xcel bills to the visit and we can set the changeover and size the strips from them. Call Sundog at (719) 417-2475 or request an estimate. The heat pump vs gas furnace guide and operating cost guide go deeper on the money side.
Get an EstimateQuestions people ask
Is electric backup heat expensive to run?
Per unit of heat, resistance strips cost more to run than a working heat pump, because they deliver one unit of heat per unit of electricity. Sized to the gap and locked out in mild weather, they run for a small share of the winter.
Can I keep my old furnace as the backup?
Often, if it is in good condition and its blower and coil can work with the heat pump. We check both on the visit; a furnace near the end of its life usually makes more sense to replace with the job.
Does backup heat come on during defrost?
In most setups, yes, briefly. It tempers the air while the outdoor coil defrosts so the registers don't blow cool air for those few minutes.

