Decision Guide

Should you repair or replace your heat pump?

The failed part, the refrigerant the system runs on and whether it ever heated the house well decide most of it.

Old beige air conditioner condenser on a cracked pad beside a brick ranchThe same house in a thermal rendering
Daylight and thermal views of the same house: where it loses heat sets the load.

Last Updated: November 2026

The short answer

Repair when a newer system that heated your Aurora home well has a failed component such as a capacitor, sensor or fan motor. Lean toward replacement when an older system on R-22 loses its compressor, when repairs keep coming, or when the house was never comfortable. When it is close, we price both in writing.

What failed decides most of it

A diagnosis comes first, because several faults look alike from inside the house: cool air in heat mode can be a defrost fault, low charge or a stuck reversing valve. Once we know the part, the choice usually narrows. The repair figures are Sundog's typical ranges for heat pump repair.

What failedSundog's typical rangeUsually leans toward
Capacitor, contactor or a loose connectionWithin $150 to $1,200Repair
Defrost sensor or control boardWithin $150 to $1,200Repair
Outdoor fan motorWithin $150 to $1,200Repair
Refrigerant leak at a reachable jointWithin $150 to $1,200 for most; more with a large rechargeRepair, if the refrigerant is still serviceable
Reversing valveWithin $1,500 to $3,500Repair on a newer system; weigh replacement on an older one
CompressorWithin $1,500 to $3,500Often replacement on an older system

Questions to ask on the repair visit

Whoever does the diagnosis, these answers give you what you need to decide. Regular maintenance readings, if you have them, help answer the third and fourth questions.

  • Which part failed, and how was it tested?
  • Is the refrigerant low, and if so, where is the leak and is it repairable?
  • What refrigerant does the system use, and is it still produced?
  • What condition are the compressor, coils and electrical parts in, beyond the failed part?
  • What does the repair cost, and what does a replacement include and cost for comparison?

How old it is, and what refrigerant it runs on

Age matters less as a number than for what it says about parts and refrigerant. The label on the outdoor unit names the refrigerant.

R-22 systems

Production and import of R-22 ended in the U.S. on January 1, 2020, under EPA rules, so servicing depends on recovered and reclaimed supply. A small repair can still make sense; a compressor or a large leak on an R-22 system usually points to replacement.

R-410A and newer

EPA's Technology Transitions rule moved new residential split systems to lower-GWP refrigerants. Existing R-410A systems can still be serviced, so a repair is often reasonable. A replacement, though, means a new matched indoor and outdoor pair: a new outdoor unit is not paired with an old coil.

Want your own number? We start from your house and your bills.

Get an Estimate

Did it ever heat the house well?

This question gets skipped more than any other, and it changes the answer.

It always kept up

The system was sized and installed to suit the house. Repairing the failed part restores what worked.

It never quite did

Cold back rooms, backup heat running often, short cycling or a whistling return. A repair restores the same problem. A replacement sized from a load calculation, with the duct problems fixed, addresses the cause. See ductwork for heat pumps.

A simple way to weigh it

No single rule covers every system, but these signs point one way or the other.

Signs for repair

A newer system, a small component failure, R-410A or a newer refrigerant, steady comfort until now and no history of repeat calls.

Signs for replacement

An older system on R-22, a failed compressor, several repairs in the last few seasons, rooms that never kept up, or an AC side that is also failing.

Signs to check further

A reversing valve on a mid-life system, or a leak that is hard to find. Here the written comparison earns its keep.

Not a deciding factor

The brand alone. Install quality, sizing and duct condition matter more to how the next system runs.

What replacement involves

If replacement wins, the work is more than swapping a box. The replacement page covers it in full; these are the compatibility checks that set its scope.

  • A new room-by-room load calculation, since the old size may have been wrong
  • Line set: reused after a flush and pressure test where it is sound and the right size, or replaced
  • Air handler or coil matched to the new outdoor unit
  • Panel and circuits checked against the new nameplate and any backup heat
  • Pad or stand, the permit and start-up readings for airflow, charge and controls

How we put both options in writing

When the answer is close, you see both prices side by side before deciding.

Routine repair$150 to $1,200Major component repair$1,500 to $3,500Cold-climate ducted replacement$13,000 to $25,000$0$10,000$20,000
Sundog's typical ranges. Your prices come from the diagnosis and the written estimate.

The repair

The failed part, the labor and any refrigerant, priced from the diagnosis. Sundog's typical range is $150 to $1,200 for routine repairs and $1,500 to $3,500 for major components.

The replacement

A written estimate with model numbers and low-temperature capacity, duct and electrical work, the permit, removal, pad or stand and start-up checks. Sundog's typical range for a cold-climate ducted system is $13,000 to $25,000, and rebates that apply to your address are listed apart from the price.

Get a diagnosis before you decide

Call (719) 417-2475 or book a repair visit. We find the cause first and price the repair against what is left of the system. If replacement comes up, the cost page shows our ranges and the rebates guide shows what can come off.

Get an Estimate

Questions people ask

Is it worth repairing an R-22 heat pump?

For a small part such as a capacitor or contactor, often yes. For a compressor or a leak that needs a large recharge, replacement usually makes more sense because R-22 is no longer produced.

Can I replace just the outdoor unit?

Sometimes, if the indoor coil or air handler is a matched, current model. With an older coil or a refrigerant change, the indoor side is replaced too so the pair matches.

Why does my heat pump blow cool air in winter?

It can be a defrost cycle, low charge, a stuck reversing valve or backup heat not engaging. A puff of steam and a short pause outside is normal defrost; cool air for long periods needs a repair visit.

Get an estimate for your Aurora house

Tell us about the house and the rooms that give you trouble. We come back with a first range from our typical rates and a time for the site visit.

CallGet an Estimate